Mona

Local Restaurants Erie, PA
Presque Island Restaurant Erie, PA
For Banquet Facility & Catering , please call 814-836-7600
For Pub and Grille, please call 814-838-2162

MAIN MENU

Main Menu

Our Presque Isle Restaurant's Main Menu
Delicious Options for the People of Erie, PA

The Colony Pub and Grille is a west-side staple located in Erie, PA. Our Presque Isle restaurant offers a casual dining experience for all featuring mouthwatering steaks, fresh seafood, and a variety of other amazing culinary creations. Stop in today; we look forward to your visit!

Welcome to dinner at the New Colony…
Featuring the Exceptional Josper Grill

Menu

Smokehouse & Ribs

Not for you if you don’t like things charred! 
New! Filet*
Your choice of petite or 8 oz. …Market Price
(med-well or well done will be butterflied)

Bone-in Rib Eye*
Hand-cut in house to your liking …Market Price

Prime Rib of Beef*
Grilled over mesquite charcoal or slow-roasted
New! 10 oz. …$15.99
Queen ….........$18.99
King …............$21.99
We do not advise cooking well done.

Black Angus Top Sirloin …Market Price

New! Stuffed Filet of Sirloin
Stuffed with red peppers, mushrooms, onion & feta cheese …$15.99
“Best Ribs in Town!”
Danish Ribs …........$18.99
Half-Rack of Ribs …$13.99
Half-Rack of Ribs with 3 Fire-Roasted BBQ Shrimp ....$17.99

*Not available on Erie Fine Dining card. These are Colony Chef Specials.

***Not Responsible for Medium-Well or Well Done Steaks***
Rare – cold center
Medium Rare – hot outside, cold red center
Medium – warm pink center
Medium Well – brown throughout
Well – charred 

Please Note: We grill all of our steaks and chicken on a fresh charcoal grill.

Menu

Menu

Ask about our daily fresh catch!
Pasta

Pick an Entrée, add Pasta and a Sauce…
Entrée 
Chicken…..............$16.99
Tenderloin Tips…..$18.99
Shrimp…................$16.99
Scallops…..............$18.99
Seafood: Shrimp, Crab and Mussels…$19.99
Roasted Veggies…$14.99

Sauce
Marinara
Alfredo (add $1.00)
Scampi
Blackened 
Cajun Butter & Garlic
Fresco: sautéed spinach, basil, garlic, tomatoes, mozzarella

Pasta
Angel Hair
Fettuccini
Penne
Available Plain:
Scampi…$13.99
Fresco…$14.99
Fettuccini Alfredo…$15.99

All CPG Dinners Come with Soup or Salad and Choice of ONE of the Following:
Baked Potato – Mashed Sweet Potato – Fresh Red Skin Mashed Potato – Pasta with Marinara – Vegetable of the Day – French Fries – Sweet Potato Fries – Coleslaw – Cottage Cheese

Add Extras to Any Meal
Lobster Tail – Cluster of Crab – 2 Pieces of Perch – Mushrooms – Fire-Roasted Veggies – Asparagus – Mushrooms, Red Peppers & Feta Cheese – Oscar (Crab Meat, Fresh Asparagus and Hollandaise Sauce) – Alexander (2 Shrimp, Crab Meat, Fresh Asparagus and Hollandaise Sauce) – Cajun – Blackened

Menu

Menu

Remember Us For All Of Your Catering / Banquet Needs!
Wakes - Showers - Weddings – Business Meetings
CPG Offers Seating For 8 To 90 – 12th Street Banquet Facility Offers Seating For Up To 275
Chocolate Fountain Available!
Delivery Available Upon Request

Consuming Raw Or Uncooked Meats, Poultry, Seafood, Shellfish Or Eggs May Increase Your Risk Of Food Borne Illness. Especially If You Have Certain Medical Conditions.
  • Write your caption here

    Button
  • Write your caption here

    Button
  • Write your caption here

    Button
Share by: